RTI Source Blog

by User Not Found | Jan 12, 2011

Progress-Monitoring:  Which Instrument?

 

by Susan L. Hall, EdD

 

In my last blog I provided an overview of one of the more critical topics in RTI―progress monitoring.  Based on questions from teachers in the field, I prepared a list of the top five progress-monitoring questions. In this blog, I’ll tackle the question: Which assessment instrument should I use?

Another way to ask this question might be: Should I use the curriculum-based measure to monitor progress since that’s what we used for benchmark screening? The answer is “It depends.” The main factor the answer depends upon is the skill that is the focus of instruction in the intervention group. The purpose of progress monitoring is to measure whether the student’s reading is improving as a result of the instruction he’s receiving. It’s impossible to tell whether any improvements are related to the core reading instruction or to the intervention instruction, but does it matter? I suggest that it doesn’t. If what we’re doing is working, then we just have to keep doing it and make sure that the rate of progress is sufficient. We want our assessment to highlight any student who is not making progress from the combination of Tier I and Tier II or III. Poor progress means that it’s time to make a change in the instruction the student is receiving.

So the key is to match the assessment instrument as closely as possible with the skill of the intervention group. Some grade 2 and above teachers assume that they should always use the oral reading fluency part of the CBM as the progress monitoring tool, but that just isn’t the case. Let’s think about it using an analogy. Imagine that a novice golfer is losing strokes whenever his ball lands in a sand trap and he asks his instructor for some help with this. His instructor just spent an hour demonstrating the ideal technique for pitching balls out of a sand trap followed by giving the golfer an opportunity to practice using his sand wedge to pitch 100 balls out of a sand trap. Now it was time to see if he got it. So the instructor sent the golfer out to play a round of 18 holes on a course that had one sand trap and then sat down to look at his data. What’s wrong with this picture? There’s a mismatch between the instrument and the skill he’s attempting to measure. The assessment gave too few data points on the exact skill they had practiced.

The same is true for reading. Using an oral reading passage to assess the progress of a student in a long vowel silent-e group is an ineffective measurement tool because there may be only one or two words that contain this pattern out of the 100 words he read. It’s important to match the instrument to the skill. The table below shows how to do this.

 

Reading Component

Intervention Group

Skill Focus

Appropriate Assessment

Instrument

Comprehension

Comprehension

Comprehension

Fluency

Fluency with Connected Text

Oral Reading Fluency (ORF) (DIBELS or AIMSweb)

Phonics

Multisyllable Words

Phonics Screener – multisyllable word section

Vowel Teams

Phonics Screener – vowel team section

Long Vowel Silent-e

Phonics Screener – long vowel silent-e section

Phonological Awareness

Initial Sound at the Phoneme Level

Initial Sound Fluency (ISF) (DIBELS)

Syllable Segmentation

Phonological Awareness Screener – syllable section

Letter Naming

Letter Names

Letter Naming Fluency (LNF) (DIBELS or AIMSweb)

 

7150 comments

Leave a comment
  1. pioneerseo | Oct 23, 2019
    The site stacking rate is stunning. It sort of feels that you're doing any particular stunt. Additionally, The substance are perfect work of art. you have completed an awesome movement regarding this matter!  안전놀이터
  2. Arora | Oct 23, 2019
  3. Vicki pine | Oct 23, 2019
    Palm trees 
  4. Rebecca Simms | Oct 23, 2019

    <ahref="www.plantstoday.com.au/">Palm trees</a> 
  5. Grant | Oct 23, 2019
    <a href="www.plantstoday.com.au/">Palm trees</a> 
  6. edawr | Oct 23, 2019
    I think this is an informative post and it is very useful and knowledgeable.Website
  7. nanny | Oct 23, 2019
    Great article Lot's of information to Read...Great Man Keep Posting and update to People..Thanks.antiques for sale uk
  8. nanny | Oct 23, 2019
    I recently found many useful information in your website especially this blog page.using a virtual office
  9. edward | Oct 23, 2019
    I have browsed most of your posts. This post is probably where I got the most Buy Negative Facebook Reviews
  10. ahmed | Oct 23, 2019
    Your site is truly cool and this is an extraordinary rousing article.Self Assessment Tax Return Accountants East Grinstead
  11. aa | Oct 23, 2019
    Cool stuff you have got and you keep update all of us. cresus casino
  12. Cyberhero | Oct 23, 2019
    I have browsed most of your posts. This post is probably where I got the most gooddrama
  13. aa | Oct 23, 2019
    It is a fantastic post – immense clear and easy to understand. I am also holding out for the sharks too that made me laugh. auto news
  14. edward | Oct 23, 2019
    Super site! I am Loving it!! Will return once more, Im taking your sustenance in addition, Thanksanilinkz
  15. asimseo1 | Oct 23, 2019
    Nice Informative Blog having nice sharing.. english on line gratis
  16. AAA | Oct 23, 2019
    I went to this website, and I believe that you have a plenty of excellent information,  I have saved your site to my bookmarks. earn money online
  17. Naveed | Oct 23, 2019
    Thanks  for another wonderful post. Where else could anybody get that type of info in such an ideal way of writing?  sous traitant
  18. buy and sell Litecoin | Oct 23, 2019
    Positive site, where did u come up with the information on this posting? I'm pleased I discovered it though, ill be checking back soon to find out what additional posts you include. buy and sell Litecoin
  19. cherry parker | Oct 23, 2019
  20. aaron wils | Oct 23, 2019
  21. aaron | Oct 23, 2019
    https://thimpress.com/forums/users/aaronwil1984/ https://www.themeinwp.com/support-forum/users/aaronwil1984/ https://www.mojomarketplace.com/user/aaronwil1984-ih2XBvcXy2 https://www.bloglovin.com/@elizataylor2/velpanat-sofosbuvir-400mgvelpatasvir-100mg https://catchthemes.com/support-forum/users/aaronwil1984/ http://forum.anarduino.com/user/profile/3273.page http://b3.zcubes.com/v.aspx?mid=1858996&title=how-much-cost-epclusa--sofosbuvir-velpatasvir--in-india
  22. Alexa | Oct 23, 2019
    Thank you very much for this valuable contribution and informative. Check our website.
    Canon Printer Support
    Canon mx922 Setup
    Canon Pixma tr8520 Setup
    Canon Pixma ts9120 wireless Setup
    Canon Pixma ts6220 Setup
    Canon Pixma g1200 setup Setup
    Canon Pixma tr4520 Setup
    Canon Printer Model Setup
    Canon Printer Setup
    Canon Printer Driver Download Setup
    Canon Pixma Wireless Printer Setup
    Ij Network Tool Setup
    Canon ij Scan Utility Setup
    Canon Printer Setup MAC
    Canon Print inkjet Selphy app Setup
    Canon Selphy cp1300 Setup
    Canon Imageprograf pro 1000 Setup
    Canon Pixma ts3120 Setup
    Canon Maxify ib4020 Setup
    Canon Maxify mb2720 Setup
    Canon Pixma ix6820 Setup
    Canon Pixma mg2522 Setup
    Canon Pixma mx492 Setup
    Canon Pixma ts302 Setup
    Canon Pixma ts9520 Setup
    Canon Pixma ts9521c Setup
    Canon Color Imageclass mf632cdw Setup
    Canon Color Image class mf733cdw Setup
    Canon Imageclass d570 Setup
    Canon Imageclass lbp612cdw Setup
    Canon Imageclass mf244dw Setup
    Canon Imageclass mf634cdw Setup
    Canon Imageclass mf731cdw Setup
    Canon ivy mini Photo Setup
    Canon Maxify ib4120 Setup
    Canon Maxify mb2020 setup Setup
    Canon Maxify mb2120 Setup
    Canon Maxify mb2320 Setup
    Canon Maxify mb5120 Setup
    Canon Pixma g2200 Setup
    Canon Pixma g4210 Setup
    Canon Pixma mx490 Setup
    Canon Pixma tr7520 Setup
    Canon Pixma ts202 Setup
    Canon Pixma ts5120 Setup
    Canon Pixma ts6120 Setup
    Canon Pixma ts702 Setup
    Canon Pixma ts8120 Setup
    Canon Pixma ts8220 Setup
    Canon Mx922 Setup
    Canon Pixma Mx922 Printer Setup
    Canon Mx922 Scanner Driver
    Canon Mx922 Wireless Setup
    Canon Mx922 Software
    Canon Mx922 Printer Setup
    Canon Mx922 Troubleshooting
    Canon Mx922 Scan Setup
    Canon Mx922 Fax Setup
    Canon Mx922 Ink Cartridge
    Canon Mx922 Best Printing Techniques
    Canon Mx922 FAQs
  23. gipp | Oct 23, 2019
    Thank you for liking, press shareI exactly got what you mean, thanks for posting. And, I am too much happy to find this website on the world of Googleข่าวกีฬาต่างประเทศข่าวฟุตบอลต่างประเทศข่าวฟุตบอลวันนี้
  24. berry | Oct 23, 2019
     Your system is not running well it can be due to some driver related or missing/out dated driver. You must try best free driver updater software for better performance.
  25. crick | Oct 23, 2019
    Thank you for liking, press shareI exactly got what you mean, thanks for posting. And, I am too much happy to find this website on the world of Googleข่าวกีฬาต่างประเทศข่าวฟุตบอลต่างประเทศข่าวฟุตบอลวันนี้
  26. mina | Oct 23, 2019
    Thank you for liking, press shareI exactly got what you mean, thanks for posting. And, I am too much happy to find this website on the world of Googleข่าวกีฬาต่างประเทศข่าวฟุตบอลต่างประเทศข่าวฟุตบอลวันนี้
  27. vera | Oct 23, 2019
    Thank you for liking, press shareI exactly got what you mean, thanks for posting. And, I am too much happy to find this website on the world of Googleข่าวกีฬาต่างประเทศข่าวฟุตบอลต่างประเทศข่าวฟุตบอลวันนี้
  28. Morkal | Oct 23, 2019
    Thanks for the information. If you are looking printer support visit here.123.hp.com | 123.hp.com/ojpro9010 | 123.hp.com/setup 9010 | 123.hp.com/ljpro m281fdw | 123.hp.com/setup m281fdw | 123.hp.com/inktank 410 | 123.hp.com/setup 410 | 123.hp.com/envy4520 | 123.hp.com/setup 4520 | 123.hp.com/ojpro9025 | 123.hp.com/setup9025 | 123.hp.com/dj2600 | 123.hp.com/setup 2600 | 123.hp.com/ojpro9015 | 123.hp.com/setup 9015 | 123.hp.com/ojp9010 | 123.hp.com/setup 9010 | 123.hp.com/ojp9010 | 123.hp.com/setup 9010 | 123.hp.com/ojp9015 | 123.hp.com/ojpro 9015 Setup | 123.hp.com/ojpro9020 | 123.hp.com/setup 9020 | 123.hp.com/ojp9025 | 123.hp.com/setup 9025 | 123.hp.com/dj2600 | 123.hp.com/setup 2600 | 123.hp.com/dj3632 | 123.hp.com/setup 3632 | 123.hp.com/ljpro m180nw | 123.hp.com/setup m180nw | 123.hp.com/envy4520 | 123.hp.com/setup 4520 | 123.hp.com/dj3630 | 123.hp.com/setup 3630 | 123.hp.com/oj5255 | 123.hp.com/setup 5255 | 123.hp.com/dj2600 Setup | 123.hp.com/oj5255 | 123.hp.com/setup 5255 | 123.hp.com/ojpro 9015 Support | 123.hp.com/setup 9015 Printer | 123.hp.com/setup4500 | 123.hp.com/envy4500 | 123.hp.com/dj3700 | 123.hp.com/setup 3700 | 123.hp.com/setup m225dw | 123.hp.com/ljpro m225dw | 123.hp.com/ojpro8710 | 123.hp.com/setup 8710 | 123.hp.com/envy7640 | 123.hp.com/setup 7640 | 123.hp.com/ojpro8610 | 123.hp.com/setup 8610 | 123.hp.com/ojpro8720 | 123.hp.com/setup 8720 | 123.hp.com/ojpro8710 | 123.hp.com/setup 8710 | 123.hp.com/ojpro8610 | 123.hp.com/setup 8610 | 123.hp.com/ojp8620 | 123.hp.com/setup 8620 | 123.hp.com/ojp9020 | 123.hp.com/setup 9020 | 123.hp.com/dj5810 | 123.hp.com/setup 5810 | 123.hp.com/oj8630 | 123.hp.com/setup 8630 | 123.hp.com/deskjet 2600 | 123.hp.com/setup 2600 | 123.hp.com/dj2652 | 123.hp.com/setup 2652 | 123.hp.com/envy4512 | 123.hp.com/setup 4512 | 123.hp.com/setup 5200 | 123.hp.com/envy 5200 | 123.hp.com/envy4512 | 123.hp.com/setup 4512 | 123.hp.com/oj3830 | 123.hp.com/setup3830 | 123.hp.com/dj2630 | 123.hp.com/setup 2630 | 123.hp.com/oj4650 | 123.hp.com/setupoj4650 | 123.hp.com/envy4502 | 123.hp.com/setup4502 | 123.hp.com/envy5665 | 123.hp.com/setup 5665 | 123.hp.com/envy4501 | 123.hp.com/setup 4501 | 123.hp.com/ojpro6970 | 123.hp.com/setup 6970 | 123.hp.com/envy4520 | 123.hp.com/setup 4520 | 123.hp.com/ojpro8625 | 123.hp.com/setup 8625 | 123.hp.com/dj2600 | 123.hp.com/setup 2600 | 
  29. aa | Oct 23, 2019
    Necessary marketing communications that you really convenient search previous to putting up. It's going to convenient to write down better write-up in which. votre page entreprise sur internet pas cher
  30. Jalapeno | Oct 23, 2019

    Don't recognize from in which to get custom boxes with logo no need to worry because you could get paper cigarette boxes and custom boxes wholesale.

  31. Renewable Energy | Oct 23, 2019
    Thanks for sharing. Keep it up. Renewable Energy Consulting Firms
  32. pinoy tvs | Oct 23, 2019
    trading forex review  Some of the links on this websites articles and comparison tables are affiliate links, which means we receive a commission should open an active account.
  33. Chritstiana Parker | Oct 23, 2019
  34. Lizey | Oct 23, 2019
    I recently found many useful information in your website especially this blog page.The Fractal Farm
  35. nanny | Oct 23, 2019
    Great article Lot's of information to Read...Great Man Keep Posting and update to People..Thanks.best linen sheets
  36. LLokok | Oct 23, 2019
    Hello, my name is bruno mars from Thailand. วิธีถนอมสายตา Excellent website Very useful to me I like this website
  37. edwar | Oct 22, 2019
    I think this is an informative post and it is very useful and knowledgeable.glodls
  38. ewad | Oct 22, 2019
    I think this is an informative post and it is very useful and knowledgeable.bgtorrentz
  39. jhonesseo | Oct 22, 2019
    You have outdone yourself this time. It is probably the best, most short step by step guide that I have ever seen. og broker
  40. eward | Oct 22, 2019
    I think this is an informative post and it is very useful and knowledgeable.happy holi pic
  41. sunji | Oct 22, 2019
    Thank you for liking, press shareI exactly got what you mean, thanks for posting. And, I am too much happy to find this website on the world of Googleข่าวกีฬาต่างประเทศข่าวฟุตบอลต่างประเทศ
  42. solo | Oct 22, 2019
    Thank you for liking, press shareI exactly got what you mean, thanks for posting. And, I am too much happy to find this website on the world of Googleข่าวกีฬาต่างประเทศข่าวฟุตบอลต่างประเทศ
  43. nana | Oct 22, 2019
    Thank you for liking, press shareI exactly got what you mean, thanks for posting. And, I am too much happy to find this website on the world of Googleข่าวกีฬาต่างประเทศข่าวฟุตบอลต่างประเทศ
  44. washing machine repair Dubai | Oct 22, 2019
    Your post is really nice. We have many years of experience in Washing machine repair Dubai Al Satwa.
  45. Washing machine repair Dubai | Oct 22, 2019
    Your post is really nice. We have many years of experience in Washing machine repair Dubai Al Satwa.
  46. lufy | Oct 22, 2019
    Thank you for liking, press shareI exactly got what you mean, thanks for posting. And, I am too much happy to find this website on the world of Googleข่าวกีฬาต่างประเทศข่าวฟุตบอลต่างประเทศ
  47. aa | Oct 22, 2019
    You have a real talent for writing unique content.  I like how you think and the way you express your views in this article.  I am impressed by your writing style a lot. Thanks for making my experience more beautiful. Brisbane Engagement Rings
  48. nanny | Oct 22, 2019
    Great article Lot's of information to Read...Great Man Keep Posting and update to People..Thanks.RESIDENTIAL PLOTS IN HYDERABAD
  49. nanny | Oct 22, 2019
    Best football tipsters, horse racing, Professional tipsters, Check out our website for daily tips, we provide top quality analysis.woosaver
  50. aa | Oct 22, 2019
    Thanks for picking out the time to discuss this, I feel great about it and love studying more on this topic. It is extremely helpful for me. Thanks for such a valuable help again. gemstone rings Sydney

    Leave a comment